Our Insight

Integrating ESG into Fund Structures Without Pandering

Summary: Offers practical approaches to incorporating ESG metrics into LPAs and fund policies—without creating unenforceable fluff. Includes sample clauses and market reception.

Content

Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) considerations have moved from the margins to the mainstream of private fund structuring. But with rising investor scrutiny and regulatory pressure, sponsors face a dilemma: how to integrate ESG authentically—without resorting to vague promises or performative clauses.

 

Here’s how sponsors can embed ESG into fund documentation with substance, not spin.

Why ESG Integration Matters
  • Investor Demand: LPs increasingly require ESG disclosures and policies as part of their due diligence.
  • Regulatory Momentum: Regimes like the EU’s SFDR and Hong Kong’s climate-related disclosure rules are reshaping fund obligations.
  • Reputational Risk: Superficial ESG language can backfire—leading to accusations of greenwashing or misrepresentation.
Where ESG Belongs in Fund Documents

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.

Document ESG Integration Points
Limited Partnership Agreement (LPA) ESG investment criteria, exclusion lists, reporting obligations
Private Placement Memorandum (PPM) ESG strategy overview, risk disclosures, alignment with LP values
Side Letters Custom ESG reporting, voting rights, co-investment terms
ESG Policy (Annex or Standalone) Detailed framework for ESG screening, monitoring, and engagement
Sample ESG Clauses That Add Value
  • Exclusion Clause: “The Fund shall not invest in entities whose primary business involves tobacco production, controversial weapons, or fossil fuel extraction.”
  • Reporting Clause: “The GP shall provide annual ESG impact reports, including metrics aligned with [SASB/UN PRI/TCFD] standards.”
  • Governance Clause: “An ESG subcommittee of the advisory board shall review portfolio alignment with stated ESG objectives.”

These clauses should be tailored to the fund’s strategy—not copied from generic templates.

Avoiding Common Pitfalls
  • Vague Language: Terms like “ESG-friendly” or “impact-oriented” without definitions or metrics invite skepticism.
  • Inconsistent Messaging: Misalignment between the PPM and LPA undermines credibility.
  • Overpromising: Commitments to ESG outcomes that are not operationally feasible can expose sponsors to legal and reputational risk.
Market Reception

According to Preqin, private market ESG funds raised over US$90 billion in 2022—triple the volume from 2020. LPs are not just asking for ESG—they’re allocating capital based on it. But they also expect transparency, accountability, and realism.

Final Thought

ESG integration isn’t a checkbox—it’s a commitment. Sponsors who embed ESG thoughtfully into fund structures signal integrity, foresight, and alignment with the future of capital markets. At Shirley Choi & Co., we help clients craft ESG frameworks that resonate with investors and regulators alike—without pandering.